A note on Winnie Walkers and Binnie Walkers

A couple of days ago I blogged about my Winnie Walker project doll. I realized I never mentioned anything about her year or value in my blog post. Since Winnie Walker and Binnie Walker are often confused, I decided a separate post was justified.

Both Winnie and Binnie were Cissy-faced walker dolls, but Winnie was made first, starting in 1953. They both had different outfits and there were other subtle differences — for instance, some later Binnie Walkers had vinyl arms that were jointed at the elbow. Also, I've never seen the wig and hairstyle that my Winnie wears on a Binnie Walker, so I think it was just Winnie who wore it.

According to Linda Crowsey's 2008 price guide, Winnie was made in 1953 and 1954, and Binnie was made in 1954 and 1955. I think Binnie was also used in 1956 for some specific dolls, such as the non-walker 1956 Wendy Bride that I have (and am actually considering selling).

Really, the best way to learn to distinguish between Winnie and Binnie is to do the research. Study listings of complete, all-original Winnie and Binnie dolls on eBay, and consult every doll book you can find. With a little persistence and a lot of attention to detail you should be able to identify your doll!